Divre Harav/Words from the Rabbi – August/September, 2010
During my visit to Camp Ramah earlier this summer, I was dovening with the boys’ cabins of my son’s aidah. For this minyan, the girls were dovening elsewhere. Periodically, the staff wanted to give both the boys and girls a single-sex prayer experience. One of the male counselors asked the boys, “How do you connect with God differently than the girls? How is boys’ spirituality different than girls?”
The campers mentioned things like praying with tallit and tefillin, and wearing a kippah. Afterwards, I mentioned to the counselor that the campers who grew up in egalitarian congregations probably couldn’t really relate to the question. The answers that were given came from non-egalitarian campers who would have thought that girls would never wear kippot, tallit, or tefillin.
I was and continue to be stumped by the question. Is there any way in which my religious expression is uniquely male? There is an underlying spirituality in the ritual surrounding athletic experiences, but God blessed me with a body that lacks the size, height, strength, and coordination for team sports (other than chess!). I can’t help thinking about poet Robert Bly’s turn to male drumming circles, but somehow sitting around a fire shirtless beating a drum and being attacked by mosquitoes doesn’t do it for me.
The religious life committee has scheduled a number of women’s Rosh Hodesh gatherings. Rosh Hodesh, the celebration of a new month, is a religious moment that even in egalitarian congregations continues to be associated with women’s spirituality. With the demise of the Sisterhood, the Religious Life committee thought that there should continue to be some women-only outlet for religious expression at Ahavas Israel.
The camp experience made me wonder whether there ought to be a male-only religious program as well. I have never seriously considered such a program, for the simple reason that my own spiritual sense has never indicated a need for a men’s group. Are there others in our community who would like a periodic male minyan or men’s study group? I’m sure that the Federation of Jewish Men’s Clubs has resources and materials that would support this kind of group.
If an Ahavas Israel Men’s Spirituality group would be meaningful to you, and if you have a suggestion as to what form it might take, I am open to suggestions.
As we approach the fall holidays, I wish each of you a good new year. May your prayers flow from your lips with sweetness, and may all of your needs – physical, emotional, and spiritual – be fulfilled.
My experiences include drumming circles. One Passover the men did the drumming & the women danced with tamborines to Miriam’s Song…fantastic!
like the idea of study group nights or sunday.
LOL!! Nope, for most people being “attacked by mosquitoes” is not high on their list of enjoyable activities.
I would like to point out that a drumming circle can be held indoors, where one is less likely to be attacked by anything other than coffee and donuts. Drumming circles are very popular with women, as it is also a practice that is ancient to women. If you would like to see how it’s done I would be happy to show you. I’m not sure Ahavas is ready for that, but I am open to being surprised.
Churches have found men’s groups to be helpful for both spiritual development and making new friendships. Sometimes the guys just need to talk to just guys without having to “filter” things for female consumption, so to speak. Mostly they consist of a study group on a subject, a book in the Bible, etc. These groups also sometimes go out for various activities of interest to them and just hang out (boat show, car show, etc.). I can help you in the resource department if you like, although admittedly, I will not be participating.
Yes – I think some men’s functions would be a good idea.
I’m open to suggestions … programs, topics, times … do we have a monthly men only minyan on Monday or Friday morning or Sunday evening? My question really is what are you looking for?